2019 was a major yr within the LNG world with many firsts. We witnessed the signing of a uncommon coal index linked LNG worth deal between Shell and Tokyo Fuel (presumably a primary ever for Japan and perhaps even on the planet). We additionally noticed two US based mostly LNG corporations announce options to HH pricing choices for contracts being signed for his or her new deliberate tasks. Not solely this, 2019 noticed file FIDs for investments of $50 billion in LNG tasks with a complete capability of 71 MTPA. Argentina noticed the primary export of LNG and the UK witnessed the biggest progress in LNG imports (Eight Million Tonnes). The incremental manufacturing for the yr 2019 was 42 Million Tonnes (MT), the best ever, surpassing 39 MT in 2010. Nevertheless, presumably essentially the most fascinating growth of all got here in direction of the latter a part of the yr when Petronet LNG Restricted (PLL), the biggest importer of LNG in India (which is among the quickest rising vitality markets around the globe), signed a 5 MTPA deal (MoU) with Tellurian – a brand new ‘LNG’ child on the block, with an modern enterprise mannequin. Underneath the deal (definitive agreements but to be signed), PLL will make investments $ 2.5 Billion in Driftwood LNG and assure $4.25 Billion of debt to acquire the appropriate to offtake 5 MTPA of LNG. This was Tellurian’s second and most essential deal to this point. Tellurian’s first deal was with Complete for 1 MTPA of LNG.
A lot has been stated and written concerning the PLL and Tellurian deal already with analysts (each inventory and commodity) digging deep into the basics of the deal and placing their bets both for or in opposition to. This text is just not an try and dissect the deal and predict the winner or loser – which is one thing that may solely turn out to be clearer with time. What strikes most within the deal is the character of the enterprise mannequin and the innovation that lies therein, one thing that the LNG world has not seen up to now. Tellurian’s enterprise mannequin is such that Companions make investments $0.5Bn to get a 3.62% share within the 27.6 MTPA Driftwood LNG mission. In addition they decide to service $0.85Bn of debt. This provides them the appropriate to elevate 1 MTPA of LNG on an FOB foundation at short-run marginal working prices. Driftwood LNG will personal fuel reserves, fuel manufacturing services, pipelines to the plant and the liquefaction plant. Companions pays working prices (together with debt service) that are estimated to be between $3.5 to S4.5/MMBtu to get LNG loaded onto the ship.
The innovation on this enterprise mannequin stems from the truth that it permits the investor to take an publicity to, and thereby additionally (to some extent) management all the worth chain (as a shareholder) from extraction of fuel to loading of LNG on the ship. This mannequin gives a purchaser like PLL a chance for vertical integration. LNG patrons have historically restricted themselves to purchasing the commodity from well-known and huge worldwide suppliers of LNG primarily due to their restricted information, understanding and functionality to take upstream and liquefaction associated dangers. Nevertheless, on this deal, PLL will take the dangers related to upstream reserves, pipelines in US, liquefaction know-how, port and marine associated dangers on its share of Driftwood LNG. Whereas the opposite investor in Tellurian (Complete) has the expertise of upstream operations, pipelines, and LNG liquefaction, PLL has none of this company functionality and expertise but. Up to now, all of PLL’s long-term LNG contracts have been totally backed up by its Promoters by way of back-to-back contracts eradicating quite a lot of threat from PLL. That is the primary occasion whereby PLL is committing to a long-term mission on the energy of its personal steadiness sheet with none commitments from its guardian firms. This can be a important departure from the previous practices for PLL and a considerable threat to tackle.
So what’s the attraction of this deal to PLL?
The truth that this deal gives PLL a chance to offtake LNG at a hard and fast price and de-link itself from the market costs (that are identified to be risky over time) is a robust driver for this deal. To this point, PLL has long-term contracts with Rasgas (now merged with Qatargas) from Qatar and ExxonMobil from Gorgon and these contract costs are linked with Crude. With this Tellurian deal, PLL has a chance to carry LNG at a hard and fast price (Worth). The true query due to this fact is whether or not this deal needs to be evaluated by itself benefit or ought to it’s evaluated by way of the danger diversification it gives PLL and Indian LNG combine.
On the earth of finance, there’s a well-understood idea of measuring the riskiness of a inventory and that of a portfolio. Measured by way of Beta, the riskiness of a portfolio is decided by the person riskiness of the elements (or shares) within the portfolio and the correlation (covariance) amongst these elements. Beta describes the exercise of a inventory or safety or a portfolio’s returns responding to swings available in the market. The beta calculation helps buyers perceive whether or not a inventory or portfolio strikes in the identical path as the remainder of the market, and the way risky or dangerous it’s in comparison with the market. Including a negatively correlated inventory with excessive Beta to an current portfolio reduces its total threat and equally including a low Beta inventory additionally reduces the general threat of the portfolio. A set worth contract or a value plus mannequin has in-effect a zero Beta (for the reason that worth doesn’t range with the commodity costs available in the market).
Analysing PLL’s and India’s current portfolio of long-term LNG contracts on this method gives an fascinating perception. Based mostly on approximations of worth system accessible in public area and interactions with business specialists, the respective figures beneath present (with and with out Tellurian deal): (1) the variation in landed worth of PLL’s long run LNG portfolio with adjustments in crude costs; (2) the variation in landed worth of India’s suite of Long run LNG contracts with adjustments in crude costs; and (3) the variation in landed worth of India’s suite of Long run LNG contracts with adjustments in Henry Hub Costs.
It’s evident from the figures above that (a) including the 5 MTPA Tellurian provide reduces the variability of the PLL and Indian LNG portfolio with crude costs and (b) the Tellurian mission will possible result in LNG being imported into India beneath the worth from the opposite HH linked offers. Zooming in on the influence on PLL’s portfolio, we see that so long as Crude stays above $50/ Bbl, the Tellurian deal will scale back the portfolio worth of PLL’s LNG. On the opposite facet when crude slips beneath $50, Tellurian LNG will enhance PLL’s common worth of long run LNG into the nation. That is precisely how threat discount have to be seen – because the discount in two-sided variability and never as a one-sided upside or draw back threat discount. Historically many have a tendency to think about threat as solely one-sided – i.e. patrons are nervous what occurs when costs rise and sellers are nervous what occurs when costs fall. Nevertheless to scale back threat, it have to be sure on each side and that is precisely what a low Beta inventory does to a portfolio and thus reduces its total threat. There are merchandise accessible to bind threat on one facet within the monetary world (by way of choices – calls, places and varied different exotics) nevertheless they don’t seem to be as continuously discovered within the commodity world (learn LNG) and may be costly to purchase (like insurance coverage) with an upfront premium.
Is PLL then not uncovered to any threat on this deal?
Fairly the opposite. PLL will take many dangers on this deal and extra considerably, these which it doesn’t have the understanding and expertise of managing. Dangers resembling upstream reserves threat, manufacturing threat, fuel pipeline threat, liquefaction know-how dangers, US regulatory threat, and different dangers related to growing a greenfield LNG terminal within the US would require a sturdy threat administration framework in place. Presumably, the previous expertise of Tellurian promoters (from Cheniere) has had an enormous function to play in getting buyers like PLL snug. Quite a bit may go flawed on this LNG chain resulting in mission delays and growing prices impacting PLL severely. PLL must rely closely on Tellurian to handle these dangers.
At a time when the favored opinion is that the LNG market will stay a patrons’ marketplace for the subsequent few years, it appears a somewhat daring resolution by PLL to commit a big funding and repair a value (worth) for itself for the LNG. With important new LNG provides searching for markets and spot costs threatening to the touch and stay at marginal prices, the strongest argument in opposition to this deal is that PLL may have maybe discovered a traditional long-term take care of modern formulae and nonetheless be capable to diversify its threat. With respect to the Indian portfolio of LNG contracts, it will be smart to do not forget that Indian firms have already got a major capability of LNG tied up underneath long-term contracts. One other giant long-term dedication resembling this may present restricted room for Indian patrons to learn from decrease spot costs.
A harbinger of a brand new sort of partnership between two international locations
Regardless of the consequence of this deal over time, most fascinating is the truth that a deal resembling this has not been accessible to LNG patrons up to now and it indicators an innovation within the LNG world. That it has come from a rustic identified for innovating can also be not a shock. For US and India, the 2 international locations concerned, it maybe reveals the essence of future Vitality Partnership to come back – one which doesn’t come by way of G2G initiatives or G2G commerce, however by way of investor owned and threat taking companies innovating their enterprise fashions and discovering mutual advantages that finally lead to a multi-billion greenback, multi-year partnership. Given the stakes concerned, the optimists would hope that this deal gives advantages to each entities over time.
DISCLAIMER: The views expressed are solely of the writer and ETEnergyworld.com doesn’t essentially subscribe to it. ETEnergyworld.com shall not be chargeable for any injury induced to any individual/organisation immediately or not directly.